Big Tech Enters New Era Of Scaled Back Ambitions As Stock Market Contracts
Wall Street wants profit, not long-term growth, and Big Tech is delivering. But at what cost?
Big Technology is a weekly newsletter dedicated to covering the tech world with honest, nuanced reporting. Join the 80,000+ subscribers who tune into Big Technology for tech news without the spin. Here’s an easy way to subscribe:
Big Tech’s recent slew of canceled projects, staff reshuffling, and calls for ‘efficiency’ is no accident. Rising interest rates have focused investors on short-term profitability and companies like Amazon, Alphabet, Meta, and Snap are responding. Amazon’s longer-term telehealth bet is finished, Facebook’s New Product Experimentation unit is shrinking, and Snap’s selfie drone is toast.
“The fucking party’s over,” said one recently departed Meta employee.
This trimming signals the start of a new era for Big Tech, one where runaway spending on tomorrow gives way to unrelenting attention on today. In this era, Big Tech will become more efficient and profitable, but also more vulnerable. Competitive challenges that otherwise might’ve been swatted away in the age of easy money will become more difficult to fend off. And other, previously unthinkable events are now plausible, especially as the Federal Reserve signals its interest in more aggressive rate hikes.
Here’s what to expect as these companies scale back their faraway ambitions and concentrate on their core:
Increased Vulnerability To Outside Challenges
Big Tech’s sustained success is a product of its ability to reinvent. Microsoft is relevant today because it embraced the cloud at Windows’ expense. Amazon began as a bookstore but now prints money via web services. Google The Search Engine transformed into a browser and mobile operating system. But betting on longer-term projects is more difficult today. Just look at Meta, whose metaverse splurge helped its share price decline 57% this year. When companies spend less on future reinventions, they open the door to displacement. That’s the risk. “Their big competitors in three years are going to be built right now,” said one ex-Snap employee. “And there's almost nothing they can do about it.”
A Less Inventive Workforce
As the tech giants work to become more efficient, they might also lose their more entrepreneurial employees, and companies filled with people working on ‘safe’ projects often become less innovative. Meta, for instance, is shuffling departments amid a “ruthless prioritization” and giving some employees 30 days to find new teams or leave. “If you're on one of these really unique teams, perhaps it’s not actually a good skill set match within the company,” said Rahul Pandey, who worked on Meta’s Portal until January. “It’s a soft way of firing people.” This doesn’t bode well for employees willing to attempt projects that might not work, which is where the best inventions often emerge.
Deeper Attachment To Current Bets
When interest rates were effectively zero, a dollar in hand returned nothing over time, so inventors gave the tech giants leeway to invest billions in initiatives that probably wouldn’t pan out immediately. With rates rising, there’s now an opportunity cost to that money. So big, longer-term bets are now more consequential than ever. Meta’s metaverse wager must work. If it’s wrong — or signals it’s lost even a little belief in its vision — things could get ugly.
Excellent Short-Term Profitability
It’s not all bad news. Companies like Alphabet and Meta have been spending so much on research and experiments that they can cut significantly and avoid short-term consequences. “You can cut 20% of your costs if you’re an Alphabet or a Meta, probably without any observable impact on near-term financials other than more short-term profitability,” said Brian Wieser, global president for business intelligence at ad agency GroupM. For the moment, these companies will likely make Wall Street very happy and shift the narrative around their sinking share prices.
Excellent Short-Term Competitiveness
As the tech giants focus on their core businesses, they should also have near-term advantages over late-stage startups seeking to compete with them. These startups’ funding sources are drying up and many don’t yet have good business discipline, taking some heat off Big Tech. “Friends of mine doing Series C, Series D, who were maybe trying to optimize for growth and had poor short-term unit economics, they're getting crushed,” said Pandey. “A company like Google or Meta, they're gonna survive.”
Big Leadership Changes
And now, the previously unthinkable. Leaders who thrived in an economy that prioritized experimentation might find life in this new era grim. This could lead to shocking departures or even sales of companies that previously seemed on stable paths. “You can see a world where Evan isn't really able to work on new ideas anymore, which is his favorite thing in the world,” the ex-Snap employee said. “And if he's not able to do that, for the first time I could see him being willing to sell.” Will Spiegel or Zuckerberg, who previously seemed destined for lifetime roles, step down? It’s unlikely, but more plausible now than a few months ago. Ditto for lower-down leaders.
Check Out Unfinished Live Today And Tomorrow (sponsored)
Unfinished Live is streaming free today and tomorrow from New York City. Check it out online or come in person and watch my interview tomorrow afternoon with Frances Haugen. All tickets are 50% off with code BIGTECH50.
What Else I’m Reading
Amazon Marketplace has an identity fraud problem. Chief Metaverse Officers do what exactly? Why Snap killed Zenly. An exploration of AI-generated art, which Getty Images just banned. Meta’s Nick Clegg speaks to Semafor. Google wants to keep political emails out of spam. Amazon’s Thursday Night Football package pays off. Flying car startup Kitty Hawk is grounded. A profile of comedian Shane Gillis. A baseball team without a home stadium lives life on the bus.
Number Of The Week
- $46 Billion
Decline in Jeff Bezos’ wealth this year, second behind Mark Zuckerberg’s $71 billion. Elon Musk is down only $6 billion, retaining his spot as the top of the Bloomberg Billionaires Index.
Quote Of The Week
“Sometimes facts that are good for an antitrust defense are bad for business."
Aaron Panner, an attorney representing Meta in an antitrust case, argued that the company isn’t really Big Tech anymore.
Advertise with Big Technology?
Advertising with Big Technology gets your product, service, or cause in front of the tech world’s top decision-makers. To reach 80,000+ plugged-in tech insiders, please reply to this email. We have availability starting in mid-October.
This Week On Big Technology Podcast: The Rise And Fall Of Facebook's Big Transparency Acquisition
Brandon Silverman is the founder of Crowdtangle, which Meta (then Facebook) acquired in 2016. Crowdtangle was once the most useful tool for marketers and publishers looking to find out what was trending on Facebook. Then, it became a favorite resource for reporters looking into how Facebook treats political content, leading to some headlines Facebook didn't like. Crowdtangle subsequently lost support within the company. Silverman left Facebook late last year and is now working with governments around the world on legislation that could mandate the type of transparency he tried to push forward inside Meta. On this episode of Big Technology Podcast, Silverman tells the Crowdtangle story from start to finish.
You can listen on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Thanks again for reading. Please share Big Technology if you like it! Also, click the heart if you like newsletters that bet on the future, even in times of rising interest rates.
Questions? Email me by responding to this email, or by writing firstname.lastname@example.org
News tips? Find me on Signal at 516-695-8680